Economic Development Takings — Know Your Rights
Not every project that claims to serve the “public interest” is legally a public use. In fact, Virginia law limits the government’s power to take private property for certain purposes. For example, the government cannot take your land just to raise tax revenue, create jobs, or hand it to a private developer.
The Kelo Decision and What Followed
In 2005, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Kelo v. City of New London. In that case, the Court ruled that a city could use eminent domain to take private homes. The city could then transfer them to a private developer as part of an economic development plan. According to the Court, this counted as a “public use” under the U.S. Constitution.
The decision caused an uproar across the country. As a result, many states, including Virginia, strengthened their own property-rights protections. These new protections go beyond what the U.S. Constitution requires.
Virginia’s Response: Statute and Constitutional Amendment
In 2007, the Virginia General Assembly passed Va. Code § 1-219.1. This law defines “public use” narrowly. Specifically, it rules out takings whose main purpose is private gain, private benefit, or private enterprise. It also rules out takings meant mainly to increase jobs or tax revenue.
Then, in 2012, Virginia voters approved an amendment to Article I, Section 11 of the Virginia Constitution. This amendment wrote the same protections directly into the state constitution, including a ban on takings for economic development alone. Because of this, a future legislature can’t weaken them without another vote of the people.
What This Means for Property Owners
Sometimes a condemning authority in Virginia claims a project is a public use. However, the real purpose may be mainly to grow the tax base, create jobs, or help a private business or developer. In that case, the project may not meet Virginia’s legal standard. This standard comes from Va. Code § 1-219.1 and Article I, Section 11 of the Virginia Constitution.
In addition, Virginia law puts the burden on the condemning authority. In other words, the authority must prove the taking is for a real public use. You do not have to prove that it isn’t.
When to Raise This Issue
Economic development reasons don’t always come with that label. For example, the authority might describe a project as blight removal, redevelopment, or infrastructure. Yet the project may mainly benefit a specific private business.
Does the stated public benefit seem tied more to a private company’s plans than to a real public use? If so, it’s worth having an attorney review whether the taking meets Virginia’s legal standard. Ideally, do this before you agree to any offer.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an “economic development” taking?
In an economic development taking, the government’s main goal is to boost the economy. For example, it may want to grow the tax base or create jobs. Often, it plans to transfer the property to a private developer. This differs from taking land for a direct public use, such as a road or a school.
Can the government take my property just to give it to a private developer?
Under Virginia law, no. Both Va. Code § 1-219.1 and Article I, Section 11 of the Virginia Constitution address this. Specifically, they say a taking mainly for private gain, private benefit, or private enterprise is not a public use.
Does Virginia allow economic development takings?
No. Virginia passed a statute in 2007 and a constitutional amendment in 2012. Since then, Virginia law has banned takings whose main purpose is raising tax revenue, creating jobs, or general economic development. However, there are narrow exceptions, such as removing a public nuisance.
What was the Kelo v. City of New London case about?
Kelo v. City of New London was a 2005 U.S. Supreme Court case. In it, a city took private homes so that it could transfer them to a private developer for an economic development project. The Court ruled that this counted as a public use under the U.S. Constitution. As a result, many states, including Virginia, passed stronger property rights protections of their own.
How can I challenge a taking that isn’t a genuine public use?
First, an attorney can compare the project’s stated purpose with the legal meaning of public use under Virginia law. Then, if the taking seems to be mainly for private gain, more tax revenue, or economic development, the attorney can challenge it. In other words, the project must serve a direct public use, not just a private one.


