Skip to content
Blog
Pipeline company granted access to survey 29 Nelson properties

<p>A Nelson County judge has made Atlantic Coast Pipeline LLC a pipeline company granted access to survey 29 properties without the owners’ permission. Read the news story below. If a pipeline company wants to survey your land, <a href=”https://www.lollarlaw.com/contact-us/”>contact us</a>.</p>

<p>Original story: <a href=”PASTE-ORIGINAL-STORY-URL-HERE”>Pipeline company granted access to survey 29 Nelson properties</a></p>

<p>By Emily Brown</p>

<h2>Pipeline Company Granted Access to Survey Nelson Land</h2>

<p>LOVINGSTON — More than a year after the lawsuits began, a judge ruled on Monday that Atlantic Coast Pipeline LLC may survey land belonging to 29 Nelson County landowners without their permission.</p>

<p>After hours of arguments Monday afternoon, Nelson Circuit Judge Michael Garrett ruled that Virginia law allows ACP to enter the defendants’ properties for surveying purposes. The ruling leaves ACP a pipeline company granted access to survey all 29 properties.</p>

<p>Aaron Ruby, a spokesman for Dominion, said, “We’re pleased with the court’s ruling. The judge today reached the same conclusion that every other state and federal court that’s looked at this issue has reached,” Ruby continued, “and that is that we have the right to perform these surveys and that they are necessary to choose the best route with the least possible impact on landowners and the environment.”</p>

<p>Dominion is heading the $5 billion, 600-mile project. The pipeline would cut through West Virginia, Virginia and North Carolina.</p>

<p>“We appreciate the tremendous thought and consideration the judge gave to these cases,” Ruby added. “He was very thorough and gave all sides the opportunity to present their case.”</p>

<h2>How the Judge Read the Word “And”</h2>

<p>Garrett based his ruling on his interpretation of the word “and” in the section of the code that reads in part:</p>

<p>“Any firm, corporation, company, or partnership, organized for the bona fide purpose of operating as a natural gas company … may make such … surveys for its proposed line or location of its works as are necessary (i) to satisfy any regulatory requirements and (ii) for the selection of the most advantageous location or route, the improvement or straightening of its line or works, changes of location or construction, or providing additional facilities …”</p>

<p>Lawyers for the 29 landowners argued that “and” should have a strictly “conjunctive” meaning. ACP, they said, would have to comply with both the “satisfy any regulatory requirements” and the “selection of the most advantageous location or route …” portions of the code.</p>

<p>However, Garrett said he believes the code says natural gas companies can survey without landowners’ permission. They only have to do so for at least one of the two purposes.</p>

<p>“We thought that’s what it would come down to,” said <a href=”https://www.lollarlaw.com/charles-chuck-lollar-sr/”>Chuck Lollar</a>, a defense attorney representing several Nelson landowners, “and we were hoping he would read ‘and’ to mean ‘a-n-d,’ just like you learned in elementary school.”</p>

<h2>Arguments Over the Need for Surveys</h2>

<p>ACP lawyers argued Monday that the surveys were important. They said the surveys help find the best route with the least impact on the environment and landowners.</p>

<p>Mike Derdeyn, an attorney representing several of the defendants, made a related point. If Garrett ruled that ACP had to satisfy both portions of the code, he argued, ACP would have had to do more. In that case, ACP would have to show it needs surveys to satisfy requirements of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission review process.</p>

<p>Garrett also denied a motion by Lollar and defense attorney Ben Perdue. The motion sought to keep Atlantic Coast Pipeline surveyors from entering their clients’ properties until the Virginia Supreme Court hands down its rulings in other ACP surveying appeals. Those appeals do not have hearing dates yet.</p>

<h2>What Happens Next After the Ruling</h2>

<p>Surveys of the 29 properties should take place in February, Ruby said. Meanwhile, the 29 landowners already received notices with dates on which surveyors intend to enter the properties, “so they know we’re going to be there,” Ruby said.</p>

<p>Garrett also heard another pipeline case separately Monday and ruled again in favor of the Atlantic Coast Pipeline. That ruling allows the company to survey land belonging to Wintergreen Country Store off Route 151 in Nellysford.</p>

<p>Judges have yet to hear several more Atlantic Coast Pipeline surveying lawsuits involving Nelson landowners.</p>

<h2>Protest Outside the Courthouse</h2>

<p>Pipeline opponents rallied Monday outside the courthouse. About 50 people displayed handmade, anti-pipeline signs ahead of the hearing. They did so as a show of support for the landowners involved in the surveying lawsuits.</p>

<p>Wisteria Johnson, another of the 29 defendants, said after the hearing that the ruling dealt a blow to her family’s history. “We’re way back in the mountain. My ancestors chose to stay back in the mountain so they could stay out of all this, and the pipeline is now coming through our property,” Johnson said. “… My family for generations has been struggling to hold onto a little piece of mountain. These people with their suits and their ties are coming in, and they’re invading it.”</p>

<p>FERC currently is reviewing the ACP. The commission has said it will make a final decision on whether to authorize the pipeline by late September.</p>

<p>Lollar Law represents property owners only, in Virginia, North Carolina and West Virginia. If a company wants to survey your land, read our <a href=”https://www.lollarlaw.com/eminent-domain-overview/”>eminent domain overview</a>, see our work on <a href=”https://www.lollarlaw.com/public-utilities/”>public utility takings</a>, or call us at 757-644-4657.</p>

Back To Top
No results found...