Skip to content
Blog
Coverage of Our Survey Appeal in the Roanoke Times

The Roanoke Times covered Lollar Law’s survey appeal for its clients. Read the original story below, and contact us if pipeline surveyors want to enter your land.

Original story: Virginia Supreme Court Agrees to Hear Another Appeal of Pipeline Surveying Law

By: Duncan Adams

Virginia Supreme Court Agrees to Hear Another Survey Appeal

The Supreme Court of Virginia has agreed to hear another appeal. The appeal challenges a controversial state law. That law allows surveyors for natural gas pipeline companies to enter private property without an owner’s consent.

Chuck Lollar is a Norfolk-based lawyer who represents six landowners along the route of the proposed Atlantic Coast Pipeline. He said he learned this week that the full court will hear the appeal he filed in May. The court has not scheduled a hearing date.

Meanwhile, survey crews working for Mountain Valley Pipeline are venturing back into the field. A circuit court hearing Thursday in Franklin County granted the pipeline company a court order to proceed with surveying a property there. Also, a Roanoke County Circuit Court judge signed an order Wednesday. It paved the way for surveyors to return to the Terry family properties on Bent Mountain.

What the Virginia Survey Law Allows

Lollar’s appeal, like two cases the high court heard in April, focuses on the law that sanctions pipeline surveying on private land. The law applies even if an owner denies permission, as long as the natural gas company has provided adequate notice as defined by the statute.

Lawmakers enacted the law in 2004. It has provoked bitter disputes between landowners and survey crews. The crews seek routes through Virginia for the proposed Mountain Valley Pipeline and the Atlantic Coast Pipeline. Each interstate project would bury a 42-inch diameter pipe designed to transport natural gas at high pressure.

Even though surveying continues, both projects say about 98 percent of that work in Virginia is complete.

Two New Challenges Before the Court

The state Supreme Court has so far upheld the survey law. But Lollar’s appeal raises two challenges the court has not previously heard.

He contends that the surveys Atlantic Coast Pipeline insisted upon were not necessary to meet regulatory requirements. He says that is one condition of the law. And he argues that the law violates the Virginia Constitution, because the surveys are an illegal taking of private property without compensation.

Lollar’s appeal contested a ruling in February 2016 by a judge in Nelson County. The judge granted a judgment Atlantic Coast sought. It sanctioned entry by surveyors on the property of landowners Lollar represents.

Lollar said in an email Thursday that he and his clients feel encouraged. The court agreed to hear the appeal without requiring oral argument Wednesday before a three-judge panel.

“We believe the Virginia Supreme Court, in granting our appeal without argument before yesterday’s writ panel, indicates a genuine interest in addressing our clients’ claims that the right to trespass statute violates their constitutional guarantees and property rights which Virginians hold dear as the guardian of every other individual right,” he said.

Earlier Rulings Upholding the Survey Law

In rulings in July, the court upheld the survey law. It did so nearly three months after hearing arguments tied to two separate appeals. One of those appeals had challenged the law’s constitutionality.

In that case, Justice William Mims wrote the court’s decision. It affirmed a 2016 judgment by an Augusta County Circuit Court judge that a “landowner has no constitutionally protected property right to exclude an authorized utility from entering his property for survey purposes.”

The court ruled that Augusta County landowner Hazel Palmer’s “right to exclude” others from her private property was not absolute.

In a separate decision also focused on Virginia’s survey law and the Atlantic Coast project, the court ruled that Atlantic Coast’s previous practice provided insufficient notice. The company had told landowners when surveying would occur by stating it would occur “on or after” a certain date.

At the time, Aaron Ruby, a spokesman for Atlantic Coast, said the company hoped the court’s decision in the Palmer case would settle constitutional questions about the survey law.

Yet others observed that new challenges might follow. They included Maureen Brady, an associate professor of law at the University of Virginia School of Law.

Public Use and the Virginia Constitution

The Palmer case did not address some aspects of the contention that surveying private property without permission represents an unconstitutional “taking” of property without compensation, she said. One example is whether the two pipelines, both proposed by private companies, will provide a “public use.”

An amendment to the state constitution holds that the General Assembly “shall pass no law whereby private property, the right to which is fundamental, shall be damaged or taken except for public use.”

It specifies that the “taking or damaging of private property is not for public use” if the primary use is for private gain or private benefit. Opponents of the two pipelines contend that the projects primarily would benefit company stockholders.

Federal Lawsuit Over Pipeline Surveys

Justin Lugar is a lawyer in Roanoke who has represented landowners resisting surveying by Mountain Valley. He has argued that when surveyors leave a property, they take with them data that has value. That data includes details about wetlands, soils, springs and the like.

Lugar also has challenged the survey law in a federal lawsuit. He filed it in Roanoke late last month on behalf of 17 plaintiffs who own 10 properties along the proposed route of the Mountain Valley Pipeline. The lawsuit alleged that surveys of private property without an owner’s permission represent unconstitutional takings.

He also tackled larger issues.

As interstate pipelines, both the Mountain Valley and Atlantic Coast projects need approval from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. If FERC approves the pipelines, each will have access to use eminent domain to acquire easements across private properties.

Lugar argued in the lawsuit that FERC should not be able to grant the power of eminent domain to a private company for its pursuit of “private pecuniary gain.”

U.S. District Court has not scheduled a hearing on Lugar’s lawsuit.

Atlantic Coast Pipeline Responds

Meanwhile, Ruby said Thursday that Atlantic Coast rejects the assertion that surveying activities are takings.

“Surveys are minimally invasive, and they typically take a day or two to complete,” he said. “In the rare case where property is damaged, we compensate the landowner as we are required to do under Virginia’s survey law.

“It’s in everyone’s interest that we choose a route with minimal impacts on the environment and landowners, and surveys are the most effective way to do that,” Ruby said.

Lollar’s appeal contends that “exercising physical dominion over property, even temporarily,” constitutes a taking of property rights.

Lollar Law represents property owners only, in Virginia, North Carolina and West Virginia. To learn how surveys and easements work, read about public utility takings or call us at 757-644-4657.

Back To Top
No results found...