Pipeline meeting: hundreds of Wilson and Nash property owners filled the Nash Agriculture Center in Nashville, NC, on Tuesday. It was the first landowner-organized meeting on the proposed Atlantic Coast Pipeline project.
Charles Lollar, a Virginia attorney who specializes in eminent domain cases, said the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) will likely approve the 550-mile pipeline. He urged landowners to use caution when they sign easement agreements.
What Eminent Domain Means for Landowners
If FERC approves the project, Dominion Resources will receive the power of eminent domain. That power allows the company to seize land for the project, because the law treats the pipeline as a public necessity.
The natural gas pipeline will have the capacity to transport 1.5 billion cubic feet of natural gas per day. The gas will originate from the Marcellus and Utica shale basins in West Virginia, Ohio and Pennsylvania. Plans call for the pipeline to extend from West Virginia through North Carolina, including areas in Wilson and Nash counties.
“The problem I have with this process is this is not government,” Lollar said. “Once they get the certificate of public necessity and convenience they’re going to have the power to acquire an easement over private property in North Carolina instantly, and I’ve got a problem with that. I’ve got a real problem with it being involuntary. They take it against your will, and you’ve got one opportunity to get compensated for it.”
Pipeline Meeting Warning: Easement Offers and Fair Market Value
Most easement offers could be close to $10,000. Lollar said that amount is not the fair market value. He also said it does not equal what Dominion Resources and other energy companies will make off the system once it’s in operation.
“The problem is, in the real world most of the values and most of the offers are well below fair market value,” he said. “They’re offering property owners like you less than what you’re entitled to receive.”
Lollar keeps busy in practice by representing clients in eminent domain and property rights’ cases. He also said landowners need to make sure easement agreements don’t include other possible uses for the easement area.
He has seen documents that list other uses, including petroleum, oil and other substances. Companies can also lay larger pipelines than originally planned.
“What they install now can change,” he said. “It’s not what you see. It’s what’s in the easement document.”
Lollar said the North Carolina pipeline, proposed at 36 inches in diameter, will likely include a total easement area of about 120 feet wide. The permanent easement area will be 50 to 60 feet wide.
Lollar believes the natural gas may not offer any benefit to West Virginia, Virginia and North Carolina. He said other natural gas lines could potentially send the gas to the Port of Hampton Roads.
“It’s going to be transported all over the United States and overseas,” Lollar said. “In all likelihood, they’re going to liquefy this gas and send it overseas.”
What the Utilities Say About the Project
Dominion and Duke Energy officials have said the pipeline will provide an expanded source of gas. They say it will help fuel economic development across the region as businesses and homes rely more on natural gas. Officials have also said the pipeline will create a new source of natural gas for the companies, some of which supply natural gas to North Carolina.
The line will have three interconnections for Piedmont Natural Gas. It will give the company a second source, so it will not have to rely solely on North Carolina’s only other pipeline, which provides natural gas from the Gulf Coast.
Dave Scanzoni, Duke Energy spokesman, said in September that the second pipeline will help ease price spikes. Last winter’s “polar vortex” caused similar spikes, which increased prices 20 to 25 percent.
Dominion, Duke Energy, Piedmont Natural Gas and AGL Resources plan to build the pipeline at an estimated cost of $4.5 billion to $5 billion, following state and federal regulatory approvals. Richmond, Va.-based Dominion has agreed to build and operate the interstate natural gas pipeline.
The pipeline’s main customers are Duke Energy Carolinas, Duke Energy Progress, Virginia Power Services Energy, Piedmont Natural Gas, Virginia Natural Gas and PSNC Energy. Together they will purchase 92 percent of the pipeline’s capacity.
Carolyn Nelefant, a Washington, D.C., attorney who previously worked for FERC, also attended the meeting. She provided information about the federal regulatory process.
Lollar Law represents property owners only, in Virginia, North Carolina and West Virginia. If a pipeline meeting comes to your county, read our eminent domain overview, see our work on public utility takings, or contact us at 757-644-4657. You can also learn how the process works on the FERC website.
